In this guide
Tone questions ask how the author feels: about the subject, about a policy, about a view they are reporting. They feel subjective, and many candidates answer them on instinct. But tone is written into the passage. It sits in particular words, qualifiers and turns, and once you know where to look you can point to the evidence just as you would for a detail question.
How the questions are asked
- "The tone of the passage is best described as…"
- "The author's attitude towards the new policy is…"
- "Which word best describes the author's view of the critics?"
Notice the second and third stems. They ask about the author's attitude to one thing, not the tone of the whole passage. An author can admire a goal and doubt a plan in the same paragraph.
Where tone comes from
- Evaluative words: "reckless", "admirable", "naive", "overdue", "thoughtful".
- Qualifiers: "perhaps", "to some extent", "arguably" soften a claim; "clearly", "undeniably" harden it.
- Turns: "while…, the reality is…", "on paper… in practice…".
- Sentence choices: rhetorical questions, understatement, exaggeration, short blunt sentences.
- What the author includes: listing past failures next to a new promise is a comment in itself.
Tone words you should know
| Direction | Word | Meaning |
|---|---|---|
| Positive | Appreciative | Recognises value or merit |
| Positive | Laudatory | Praising strongly |
| Positive | Optimistic | Expects a good outcome |
| Negative | Critical | Finds fault, with reasons |
| Negative | Scathing | Harshly, severely critical |
| Negative | Sceptical | Doubts a claim; wants proof |
| Negative | Cynical | Assumes bad motives in people |
| Negative | Sarcastic | Mocking, often by saying the opposite, to wound |
| Neutral | Objective | Balanced; sets out facts without judging |
| Neutral | Analytical | Examines parts and causes |
| Mixed | Ambivalent | Holds opposing feelings at once |
| Mixed | Measured | Careful and restrained, weighing both sides |
| Other | Ironic | Meaning differs from the literal words |
| Other | Nostalgic | Longing for a past time |
| Other | Cautionary | Warning of a danger |
| Other | Wistful | Gently sad and longing |
Close pairs that trip candidates
| Pair | The difference |
|---|---|
| Sceptical and cynical | The sceptic doubts a claim. The cynic distrusts people's motives. |
| Critical and scathing | Same direction, different intensity. Scathing is harsh and often personal. |
| Objective and indifferent | Objective means balanced. Indifferent means not caring, which careful writers rarely are. |
| Ironic and sarcastic | Irony can be gentle or wry. Sarcasm is mocking and meant to sting. |
| Ambivalent and neutral | Ambivalent means feeling both ways. Neutral means not taking a side at all. |
| Nostalgic and wistful | Both look back; nostalgic stresses fondness for the past, wistful a gentle sadness. |
A three-step method
- Direction. Is the author positive, negative, neutral or mixed about the target? Eliminate options in the wrong direction first.
- Intensity. How strong is the language? "Flawed" is not "disastrous". Eliminate options that are too strong or too weak.
- Target. Is the question about the whole passage or one thing within it? Check that your answer describes the right target.
Worked example 1
The new rules on hoardings are, on paper, a model of good sense. They limit the size of advertisements near junctions, ban flashing displays that distract drivers, and set fines for violations. Whether any of this will change what we see on our roads is another matter. The city has had rules on hoardings for twenty years; what it has lacked is anyone willing to enforce them. One hopes the new rules will fare better. Past experience does not encourage optimism.
Q1. The author's attitude towards the new rules is best described as:
(a) enthusiastic
(b) indifferent
(c) hostile
(d) approving of their content but sceptical about their enforcement
Answer: (d). "On paper, a model of good sense" approves; "another matter" and "past experience" doubt.
- (a) ignores the second half and is too strong.
- (c) is the wrong direction; the author praises the rules themselves.
- (b) fails because the author clearly cares about the outcome.
Q2. The last two sentences are best described as:
(a) despairing
(b) guarded
(c) jubilant
(d) sarcastic
Answer: (b). "One hopes" keeps a little hope; "does not encourage optimism" holds it back.
- (a) is too strong; despair means no hope at all.
- (c) is the wrong direction.
- (d) does not fit, because nothing is mocked and the words mean what they say.
Worked example 2
My grandfather's bicycle still leans against the wall of the old house, its black paint faded to grey. As a child I rode on its carrier to the weekly market, holding his shirt as he pedalled past the fields. Nobody has ridden it in years. I cannot bring myself to sell it.
The tone of the passage is:
(a) nostalgic and tender
(b) critical
(c) humorous
(d) detached
Answer: (a). A childhood memory, a loved person and "I cannot bring myself to sell it" all signal fond longing. (b) has no target: nothing is being judged. (c) has no jokes. (d) is the opposite of the personal, affectionate voice.
Why moderate options usually win
CLAT passages are chosen from careful writers who rarely take extreme positions. When two options point the same way but differ in strength, such as "critical" and "scathing", the milder one is more often right. This is a tendency, not a rule. If the passage calls a policy "a disgrace" and "an insult to citizens", scathing may be exactly right. Let the evidence decide.
Practice set
Choose the best description of the tone of each extract.
P1. "The minister's claim that the scheme has 'transformed every village' will come as news to the villages."
(a) appreciative (b) neutral (c) ironic (d) nostalgic
P2. "The study is careful, its sample large and its conclusions modest. It deserves wider attention than it has received."
(a) indifferent (b) sceptical (c) ambivalent (d) appreciative
P3. "The proposal would save money and cut delays; it would also remove the last check on how the funds are spent. It is hard to know whether to welcome it or fear it."
(a) enthusiastic (b) hostile (c) ambivalent (d) objective
P4. "The report lists the rainfall figures for each district, compares them with the long-term average and notes where the gap is largest."
(a) objective (b) cautionary (c) critical (d) wistful
P5. "The committee's report, though long overdue, offers a thoughtful framework, one that ministers would do well to read before dismissing it."
(a) scathing (b) appreciative, with mild criticism (c) cynical (d) indifferent
Answers:
- (c). The literal words sound polite, but the meaning is that villages have seen no change. (a) and (b) miss the mockery. (d) is irrelevant.
- (d). "Careful", "modest" and "deserves wider attention" praise the study. There is no doubt, no mixed feeling and no lack of interest.
- (c). One benefit and one danger, and the author says they cannot decide. (a) and (b) each take one side. (d) is close but misses the stated personal uncertainty.
- (a). It reports facts with no evaluative words. The others all need judgement or feeling that is absent.
- (b). "Thoughtful" praises; "long overdue" and "before dismissing it" criticise mildly. (a) is far too strong. (c) is wrong because the author is not attacking motives, and (d) because the author clearly cares.
What to do next
- Underline the evaluative words in one editorial a day for a week, and name the tone in one word.
- Learn the close pairs table until you can explain each difference aloud.
- Read vocabulary in context, since tone often depends on one word's exact meaning, and revisit inference questions.
A note on dates and numbers. Exam patterns, vacancies and schedules change from year to year. Always confirm the current details in the latest notification on the Consortium of National Law Universities website .
Get the next CLAT guide by email
New guides every week. No spam, unsubscribe any time.