In this guide
In December 2022, the Allahabad High Court's Lucknow bench set aside the state's notification of OBC reservation for urban local body elections, because the "triple test" laid down by the Supreme Court had not been followed. The state set up a dedicated OBC commission, and the elections were held in May 2023 after its report. The episode is a neat summary of how urban local government in UP works: constitutionally protected, legally complex, and politically important.
The legal framework
| Law | Covers |
|---|---|
| UP Municipalities Act, 1916 | Nagar Palika Parishads (municipal councils) and Nagar Panchayats |
| UP Municipal Corporation Act, 1959 (Nagar Nigam Adhiniyam) | Nagar Nigams (municipal corporations) |
| 74th Constitutional Amendment (1992) — Part IXA | Constitutional status: five-year terms, reservation, State Election Commission, State Finance Commission, Twelfth Schedule |
UP amended its laws in 1994 to conform to the 74th Amendment.
Three types of urban bodies
| Body | For | Head |
|---|---|---|
| Nagar Nigam (Municipal Corporation) | Large cities | Mayor (Mahapaur), directly elected; Municipal Commissioner is the executive head |
| Nagar Palika Parishad (Municipal Council) | Medium towns | Chairperson (Adhyaksh), directly elected; Executive Officer |
| Nagar Panchayat | Transitional areas moving from rural to urban | Chairperson, directly elected; Executive Officer |
UP had 17 municipal corporations at the 2023 elections: Lucknow, Kanpur, Ghaziabad, Agra, Varanasi, Meerut, Prayagraj, Bareilly, Aligarh, Moradabad, Saharanpur, Gorakhpur, Firozabad, Jhansi, Mathura–Vrindavan, Ayodhya and Shahjahanpur (the newest). Altogether, about 760 urban local bodies went to the polls.
The mayor and the commissioner
Direct election gives the mayor a personal mandate, but the Municipal Commissioner — usually an IAS or PCS officer appointed by the state — controls the administration and staff. Mayors often complain of having legitimacy without authority. This "dual control" is a standard Mains theme.
Wards elect corporators (parshads). Committees such as the Executive Committee (Karyakarini) handle much of the business.
Other players in the city
Urban governance in UP is fragmented. Besides the municipal body, a city may have:
- a development authority (e.g., Lucknow Development Authority) for planning and land;
- Jal Sansthan for water supply;
- Awas Vikas Parishad for housing;
- Special Purpose Vehicles for Smart City projects;
- Industrial development authorities in Noida, Greater Noida and along the Yamuna Expressway — these towns are governed by authorities rather than elected municipalities.
The OBC reservation case (2022–23)
- The Supreme Court (in K. Krishna Murthy, 2010, and Vikas Kishanrao Gawali, 2021) held that OBC reservation in local bodies requires a triple test:
- a dedicated commission to study backwardness in local bodies;
- reservation proportions based on its findings;
- total reservation not exceeding 50%.
- UP's notification for the 2022 elections did not follow this, and the High Court set it aside.
- The state constituted a dedicated OBC commission headed by a retired High Court judge; the Supreme Court permitted elections after its report, and they were held in 2023 with OBC reservation.
Finances
- Own revenue — property tax, water tax, fees and user charges — is low relative to needs.
- Heavy reliance on State Finance Commission transfers and Central Finance Commission grants.
- Municipal bonds: Lucknow (2020) and Ghaziabad (2021) raised money through municipal bonds — among the first in North India.
Problems and reforms
| Problem | Reform |
|---|---|
| Weak finances | Property tax reform (GIS mapping); user charges; bonds |
| Fragmented agencies | Bring water, planning and transport under metropolitan or municipal coordination |
| Dual control | Clearer powers for elected mayors; accountability for commissioners |
| Staff shortages | Municipal cadre; technical recruitment |
| Low participation | Ward committees; area sabhas; participatory budgeting |
| Planning | Master plans implemented; metropolitan planning committees (Article 243ZE) |
Practice
Prelims-style:
- Which Act governs Nagar Palika Parishads in UP?
- How are mayors chosen in UP?
- Which was the 17th municipal corporation to be formed?
- What is the "triple test"?
- Which two UP cities issued municipal bonds?
Mains-style:
- "Urban local bodies in UP have mandates without means." Discuss.
- Examine the implications of the triple-test requirement for OBC reservation in local bodies.
A note on dates and numbers. Exam patterns, vacancies and schedules change from year to year. Always confirm the current details in the latest notification on the Uttar Pradesh Public Service Commission website .
Get the next UPPSC guide by email
New guides every week. No spam, unsubscribe any time.