In this guide
Indian banking has lived through more change in the last decade than in the thirty years before: the asset quality review, the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, UPI, large public sector bank mergers and a steady shift of customers from branches to phones. Each of these was a change management problem as much as a financial one. Paper III tests the models (Lewin, Kotter and others, with correct attribution) and asks you to apply them to exactly these events.
Forces for change
| Source | Examples |
|---|---|
| Technology | Core banking, UPI, digital lending, AI in credit and fraud detection |
| Regulation | Capital norms, stressed-asset frameworks, new customer-protection rules |
| Competition | Fintechs, payments banks, small finance banks |
| Structure | Mergers, restructuring, consolidation of regional rural banks |
| People and customers | Younger staff, customers expecting round-the-clock service |
Change can be incremental (continuous improvement of a process) or transformational (a merger or new operating model). It can be planned from the top or emergent, arising from many small adaptations.
Kurt Lewin: three stages and force-field analysis
Kurt Lewin, writing in the 1940s, gave the classic three-step model:
- Unfreeze: make people see that the present way cannot continue. Share data, create dissatisfaction with the status quo, reduce fear.
- Change (moving): introduce new processes, structures and behaviours, with training and support.
- Refreeze: lock in the new way through policies, systems, rewards and culture, so people do not drift back.
Lewin also gave force-field analysis. Any situation is held in balance between driving forces (pushing for change) and restraining forces (resisting it). To move the balance, you can strengthen drivers or weaken restrainers. Lewin argued that weakening restrainers usually works better, because pushing harder raises tension and resistance.
Worked example: force-field analysis
A bank wants branch staff to move loan processing to a new digital platform. Each force is scored 1 (weak) to 5 (strong).
| Driving forces | Score | Restraining forces | Score |
|---|---|---|---|
| Regulatory and audit push for digital records | 5 | Fear of job loss | 5 |
| Customers want faster sanction | 4 | Lack of skills on the new system | 4 |
| Lower processing cost | 3 | Habit and comfort with paper files | 2 |
| Total | 12 | Total | 11 |
- Net force for change: 12 − 11 = +1. The balance tips only slightly; change will be slow and fragile.
- Option A, push harder: add a cash incentive (driver +2). Net becomes 14 − 11 = +3, but fear and skill gaps remain.
- Option B, reduce restraints: a clear no-retrenchment assurance cuts fear from 5 to 2, and hands-on training cuts the skills gap from 4 to 1. Restraining total = 2 + 1 + 2 = 5. Net becomes 12 − 5 = +7.
Option B produces a larger shift with less conflict, which is Lewin's point.
Kotter's eight steps
John Kotter set out the model in "Leading Change: Why Transformation Efforts Fail" (Harvard Business Review, 1995) and the book Leading Change (1996).
- Establish a sense of urgency.
- Create a guiding coalition.
- Develop a vision and strategy.
- Communicate the change vision.
- Empower broad-based action (remove obstacles).
- Generate short-term wins.
- Consolidate gains and produce more change.
- Anchor new approaches in the culture.
Kotter's article listed the matching errors: complacency, a weak coalition, underestimating vision, under-communicating by a factor of ten, letting obstacles block the vision, no short-term wins, declaring victory too soon, and not anchoring change in culture.
Other models worth knowing
| Model | Author | Core idea |
|---|---|---|
| ADKAR | Jeff Hiatt (Prosci) | Individual change needs Awareness, Desire, Knowledge, Ability, Reinforcement |
| 7S framework | Tom Peters and Robert Waterman, at McKinsey (around 1980) | Strategy, structure, systems, shared values, style, staff, skills must fit together |
| Change curve | Adapted from Elisabeth Kübler-Ross's stages of grief (1969) | Denial, anger, bargaining, depression, acceptance |
| Transition model | William Bridges | Ending, neutral zone, new beginning: change is external, transition is psychological |
| Point | Lewin | Kotter |
|---|---|---|
| Steps | 3 | 8 |
| Focus | Psychological state of the group | Leadership actions |
| Strength | Simple, universal | Practical, detailed |
| Criticism | Too linear for continuous change | Top-down; sequence can be rigid |
Resistance to change
Why people resist: fear of the unknown, loss of status or job security, habit, loss of skills that mattered, distrust of management, peer pressure and poor communication.
Lester Coch and John French's 1948 study at the Harwood pajama factory in Virginia found that workers who participated in designing a change resisted it far less than those who did not. Participation remains the most cited remedy.
John Kotter and Leonard Schlesinger ("Choosing Strategies for Change", HBR, 1979) gave six approaches:
| Approach | Use when | Drawback |
|---|---|---|
| Education and communication | Resistance comes from lack of information | Slow with many people |
| Participation and involvement | Initiators lack full information; others can resist strongly | Time-consuming |
| Facilitation and support | Resistance comes from anxiety | Costly, may still fail |
| Negotiation and agreement | A group will clearly lose and has power | Expensive; invites others to bargain |
| Manipulation and co-optation | Other tactics fail or are too costly | Backfires if discovered |
| Explicit and implicit coercion | Speed is essential and initiators have power | Leaves resentment |
Applying it to Indian banking
- Public sector bank mergers. State Bank of India absorbed its associate banks and Bharatiya Mahila Bank from 1 April 2017. Bank of Baroda merged with Vijaya Bank and Dena Bank from 1 April 2019. Ten banks were combined into four from 1 April 2020 (Oriental Bank of Commerce and United Bank into Punjab National Bank; Syndicate Bank into Canara Bank; Andhra Bank and Corporation Bank into Union Bank of India; Allahabad Bank into Indian Bank). The number of public sector banks fell from 27 to 12. Each merger meant integrating core banking systems, harmonising HR policies and pay, rationalising branches and blending cultures.
- Regional rural banks have also been consolidated in stages, with a "one state, one RRB" round in 2025.
- Digitisation: core banking in the 2000s and UPI from 2016 changed branch work and required large-scale retraining.
Model answer outline (15 marks)
Question: Using a change management model, explain how the merger of two public sector banks can be managed successfully.
- Introduction: mergers as structural change; systems merge in months, cultures take years.
- Kotter applied: urgency (scale, capital, competition); coalition of top management from both banks and union representatives; vision of a stronger combined bank; communication to staff and customers; remove obstacles (IT integration, HR harmonisation); short-term wins (smooth system migration, no customer disruption); consolidate (rationalise overlapping branches); anchor (common values, training).
- Resistance: fear over postings, seniority and status of staff from the smaller bank; use participation, support and negotiation (Kotter and Schlesinger).
- Lewin's refreeze: unified policies and rewards.
- Conclusion: people, not only systems, decide whether a merger succeeds.
Short model answer (10 marks)
Question: Explain Lewin's three-stage model of change with an example from banking.
Kurt Lewin saw organisations as held in balance between forces for and against change. To change, the balance must be disturbed, shifted and then stabilised.
Unfreezing prepares people. Suppose a bank moves from paper-based to fully digital retail loan processing. Management shares data on delays and lost customers, explains regulatory expectations and reassures staff that jobs will be redeployed, not cut. This lowers restraining forces.
Changing introduces the new system. Staff are trained, champions are appointed in each branch, and early problems are fixed quickly.
Refreezing makes the new way permanent. Paper files are withdrawn, turnaround time becomes a performance measure, and branches that adopt well are recognised.
The model's strength is its simplicity and its insight that change fails without preparation and consolidation. Its weakness is that it treats change as a single episode, whereas digital banking is continuous change. Many writers therefore treat "refreezing" as building a culture that is comfortable with ongoing change.
Practice questions
- What are the three stages in Lewin's model?
- Unfreeze, change, refreeze.
- According to Lewin, which usually works better: increasing driving forces or reducing restraining forces?
- Reducing restraining forces.
- What is Kotter's first step?
- Establishing a sense of urgency.
- What does ADKAR stand for?
- Awareness, Desire, Knowledge, Ability, Reinforcement.
- Which Kotter–Schlesinger approach suits resistance caused by lack of information?
- Education and communication.
- With effect from which date were ten public sector banks merged into four?
- 1 April 2020.
What to do next
- Learn Kotter's eight steps in order and one merger example for each.
- Draw a force-field diagram for a change at your college or workplace.
- Type the 15-mark merger answer in 600 words.
- Revise the communication guide and the leadership guide.
A note on dates and numbers. Exam patterns, vacancies and schedules change from year to year. Always confirm the current details in the latest notification on the Reserve Bank of India website .
Get the next RBI Grade B guide by email
New guides every week. No spam, unsubscribe any time.