In this guide
A bank runs on other people's money and a regulator runs on public power. Both depend on trust, which is slow to build and quick to lose. That is why ethics sits inside the management syllabus of Paper III, and why interview panels often probe it too. Questions range from definitions (what is a conflict of interest?) to applied dilemmas (a branch head under target pressure) and policy (how to stop mis-selling).
The skill being tested is judgement you can explain. A good answer names the issue, applies a principle, weighs the options and lands on a defensible decision.
Ethics, values and law
- Ethics: principles of right and wrong conduct.
- Values: lasting beliefs about what matters, such as integrity, fairness and service.
- Law: rules the state enforces.
Law is a floor, not a ceiling. Selling a legal but unsuitable insurance policy to an elderly depositor may break no statute and still be wrong. Mahatma Gandhi's list of seven social sins, published in Young India in 1925, includes "commerce without morality" and "wealth without work", a compact way to open an answer on business ethics.
Ethical theories
| Approach | Thinker | Question it asks | Banking illustration |
|---|---|---|---|
| Utilitarianism (consequences) | Jeremy Bentham, John Stuart Mill | Which action gives the greatest good for the greatest number? | Restructuring a stressed loan to save jobs and recover more |
| Deontology (duty) | Immanuel Kant | Which duty or rule applies, whatever the outcome? | Never breach customer confidentiality, even to help a sale |
| Virtue ethics | Aristotle | What would a person of good character do? | Honesty with a customer even when no one would find out |
| Justice as fairness | John Rawls (A Theory of Justice, 1971) | Would I accept this rule behind a "veil of ignorance"? | Fair access to credit for small borrowers |
| Rights | Various | Whose rights are affected? | A borrower's right to be told the true cost of a loan |
Kant's categorical imperative has two forms worth remembering: act only on a rule you could will to be universal, and treat people as ends, never merely as means. Mis-selling fails both tests.
Why people in banks do wrong: the fraud triangle
Donald Cressey, studying embezzlers in the 1950s, identified three conditions that usually come together:
- Pressure: a financial need or an impossible target.
- Opportunity: weak controls, no maker–checker separation, no job rotation.
- Rationalisation: "I'll put it back", "everyone does it", "the bank won't miss it".
This gives a neat structure for prevention: reduce pressure (realistic targets, employee support), remove opportunity (controls, rotation, audit), and challenge rationalisation (culture, training, visible consequences).
Common ethical issues in banking
| Issue | Example | Safeguard |
|---|---|---|
| Conflict of interest | Sanctioning a loan to a relative's firm | Disclosure and recusal |
| Mis-selling | Pushing an unsuitable third-party product to meet a target | Suitability assessment; incentive design |
| Confidentiality | Sharing account details with an outsider | Access controls; discipline |
| Gifts and hospitality | Accepting favours from a borrower or regulated entity | Gift registers; clear limits |
| Pressure from above | Being asked to "adjust" classification of a stressed account | Escalation; documentation; audit |
| Insider information | Trading on unpublished price-sensitive information | Insider trading rules; blackout periods |
For customers, the RBI's Charter of Customer Rights (2014) sets out five rights: fair treatment; transparency, fair and honest dealing; suitability; privacy; and grievance redress and compensation. The Reserve Bank – Integrated Ombudsman Scheme (2021) provides one channel for complaints.
Whistle-blowing
Whistle-blowing is reporting wrongdoing inside an organisation through proper channels. The Indian framework has several parts:
- The Companies Act, 2013 (Section 177) requires listed companies and certain others to set up a vigil mechanism for directors and employees.
- The Whistle Blowers Protection Act, 2014 covers disclosures about public servants, though its operation has been delayed.
- The Central Vigilance Commission receives complaints under a 2004 government resolution on public interest disclosures.
- Banks have their own protected disclosure and vigil policies.
A good system guarantees confidentiality, protects against retaliation, investigates promptly and also discourages frivolous complaints.
Ethics and CSR
Archie Carroll's CSR pyramid (1991) has four layers, from the base up: economic (be profitable), legal (obey the law), ethical (do what is right beyond the law) and philanthropic (be a good corporate citizen). In India, Section 135 of the Companies Act, 2013 requires companies above set thresholds to spend at least 2 per cent of average net profit of the preceding three years on CSR.
A framework for dilemmas
- Identify the issue and the stakeholders.
- Establish the facts; don't assume.
- Check the rules: law, RBI directions, code of conduct.
- List the options, including escalation.
- Test each option: consequences, duties, character. Add Kenneth Blanchard and Norman Vincent Peale's three questions (1988): Is it legal? Is it balanced? How will it make me feel about myself?
- Decide, act and document.
Worked dilemma
A branch manager's regional head asks them to delay marking a large borrower's account as NPA by a month, "until the quarter closes", promising the borrower will pay.
- Issue: accurate asset classification versus pressure from a superior.
- Facts: is the account actually past 90 days overdue? What does the borrower's cash flow show?
- Rules: income recognition and asset classification norms are not discretionary; misclassification misleads the board, auditors, depositors and the regulator.
- Options: comply; refuse silently; classify correctly and explain in writing; escalate.
- Test: complying may look kind but hides risk and could snowball into a larger fraud (fraud triangle: pressure plus opportunity). A duty-based view forbids it. A person of integrity would not.
- Decision: classify correctly, record the reasons, inform the regional head in writing and, if pressure continues, use the vigil mechanism. Separately, work with the borrower on a genuine resolution plan.
Model answer outline (15 marks)
Question: "Targets without ethics lead to mis-selling." Discuss in the context of Indian banks and suggest measures.
- Introduction: banks sell third-party products; targets drive fee income.
- How targets cause mis-selling: pressure (fraud triangle), incentive design, information gap with customers.
- Consequences: customer losses, complaints, reputational damage, regulatory action, loss of trust in public sector banks especially.
- Measures: suitability assessment; incentives linked to quality (persistency, complaints) not only volume; ban on bundling; training; mystery shopping; grievance redress; board oversight; consequences for managers who set impossible targets.
- Ethical lens: Kant's "people as ends"; the Charter of Customer Rights.
- Conclusion: sustainable business depends on trust.
Short model answer (10 marks)
Question: What is a conflict of interest? How should a public official handle it?
A conflict of interest arises when a person's private interest could influence, or appear to influence, the performance of their official duty. The interest may be financial (a shareholding in a company being inspected), personal (a relative applying for a loan) or professional (a former employer now regulated by the official's department).
The appearance matters as much as the reality. Even if the official would decide fairly, public confidence suffers if the link is hidden.
The first step is disclosure: declare the interest in writing to the appropriate authority. The second is recusal: step away from the decision and let an independent colleague handle it. Where the conflict is continuing, the official may need to divest the interest or accept a transfer. Gifts and hospitality from interested parties should be declined or recorded under the rules. Throughout, the official should document what was done.
The principle is simple: public power must be exercised for the public, not for oneself or one's circle.
Practice questions
- Who proposed the "veil of ignorance"?
- John Rawls.
- Name the three elements of the fraud triangle.
- Pressure, opportunity, rationalisation.
- Which layer forms the base of Carroll's CSR pyramid?
- Economic responsibility.
- Which section of the Companies Act, 2013 deals with CSR spending?
- Section 135.
- Which ethical approach asks "what would a person of good character do?"
- Virtue ethics.
- What is the first step in handling a conflict of interest?
- Disclosure.
What to do next
- Memorise the theories table with one banking example each.
- Practise the six-step framework on two dilemmas: gifts from a borrower, and a colleague's cash shortfall.
- Type the 15-mark outline into a full answer.
- Revise the HRM guide and the corporate governance guide.
A note on dates and numbers. Exam patterns, vacancies and schedules change from year to year. Always confirm the current details in the latest notification on the Reserve Bank of India website .
Get the next RBI Grade B guide by email
New guides every week. No spam, unsubscribe any time.