Skip to content
Buy on Amazon and Flipkart

Contract law: consideration and capacity

An agreement becomes a contract only if something of value passes and both parties are competent. Consideration under Section 2(d), the three exceptions in Section 25, and the rules on minors and unsound mind, with a CLAT-style passage.

14 Nov 2026 8 min read

In this guide
  1. Consideration: what Section 2(d) actually says
  2. Section 25: no consideration, no contract, with three exceptions
  3. Capacity: who can contract
  4. Practice passage
  5. Revise this

Offer and acceptance give you an agreement. Two further questions decide whether the law will enforce it. Did something of value pass in return for the promise? And were both parties legally able to make it? CLAT likes both, because each has a clean rule with sharp exceptions, and the facts can be tuned so that one detail flips the answer.

This guide assumes you know offer and acceptance. It covers consideration and capacity, then gives you a practice passage.

Consideration: what Section 2(d) actually says

Section 2(d) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 defines consideration. Broken into elements:

  1. At the desire of the promisor. The act must be done because the promisor wanted it done.
  2. By the promisee or any other person. It need not come from the person who enforces the promise.
  3. An act, an abstinence or a promise. Doing something, not doing something, or promising either.
  4. Past, present or future. "Has done", "does" or "promises to do".

At the desire of the promisor

In Durga Prasad v Baldeo (1880), the plaintiff built shops in a market at the request of the Collector. The defendant, who later occupied a shop, promised the plaintiff a commission on goods sold there. The promise was unenforceable. The shops were built at the Collector's desire, not the defendant's, so there was no consideration for the defendant's promise.

From the promisee or any other person

Indian law is wider than English law here. In Chinnaya v Ramayya (1882), a woman gifted property to her daughter, who in return promised the woman's brother an annual sum. When the daughter stopped paying, the brother sued and succeeded. The consideration had moved from the mother, and the Act allows it to come from "any other person".

Past consideration and adequacy

Because Section 2(d) says "has done", past consideration is valid in India, provided the act was done at the promisor's desire. Consideration also need not be adequate. Explanation 2 to Section 25 says an agreement is not void merely because the consideration is inadequate, though a court may consider inadequacy when deciding whether consent was freely given. It must, however, be real and lawful. An unlawful consideration makes the agreement void, which is covered in void agreements.

Section 25: no consideration, no contract, with three exceptions

An agreement without consideration is void, except in three cases.

ExceptionConditions that must all be metExample
Natural love and affectionIn writing, registered, between parties in a near relation, made out of natural love and affectionA registered deed in which a person promises a sibling ₹1 lakh
Compensation for past voluntary serviceThe promisee voluntarily did something for the promisor, or something the promisor was legally compellable to doA finds B's lost purse and returns it; B later promises A ₹500
Time-barred debtA written promise, signed by the debtor or their agent, to pay all or part of a debt barred by limitationA debtor signs a letter promising to pay ₹20,000 of a time-barred debt

A completed gift is not affected: once property has actually been given, the lack of consideration does not undo the gift.

Capacity: who can contract

Section 11 says a person is competent to contract if they have reached the age of majority under the law they are subject to, are of sound mind, and are not disqualified by any law. The age of majority is generally 18 under the Indian Majority Act, 1875.

Minors after Mohori Bibee

In Mohori Bibee v Dharmodas Ghose (1903), a minor mortgaged his property to a moneylender, whose agent knew he was a minor. The Privy Council held that a minor's agreement is void from the beginning. The moneylender could not recover the money already advanced.

The consequences follow from "void from the beginning":

RuleWhat it means
No enforcement against the minorThe other party cannot sue the minor on the agreement
No ratificationThe minor cannot validate the agreement on turning 18; a fresh contract is needed
No estoppelA minor who lied about their age is still not bound by the agreement
NecessariesUnder Section 68, a supplier of necessaries is reimbursed from the minor's property, not by the minor personally
Minor as beneficiaryA minor can receive benefits, for example as the payee of a promissory note, without being bound in return

The Section 68 claim is explained in contingent and quasi-contracts.

Unsound mind and disqualification

Under Section 12, a person is of sound mind for contracting if, when making the contract, they can understand it and form a rational judgement about its effect on their interests. A person who is usually of unsound mind but occasionally of sound mind may contract during a sound period. A person usually of sound mind cannot contract while temporarily of unsound mind, for example while delirious with fever or too drunk to understand.

Other persons may be disqualified by specific laws. A passage will tell you if that is in play.

Practice passage

Passage

An agreement is enforceable only if it is supported by consideration. Consideration is something done, not done, or promised in return for a promise, and it must be done at the desire of the person making the promise. It does not matter who provides it: the consideration may come from the promisee or from any other person, and a promisee who personally gave nothing may still enforce the promise if someone else provided the consideration.

An agreement without consideration is void. There are three exceptions. First, a promise made in writing and registered, out of natural love and affection, between parties standing in a near relation to each other. Second, a promise to compensate a person who has already voluntarily done something for the promisor. Third, a written promise, signed by the debtor, to pay a debt that can no longer be recovered because of the law of limitation.

The law also protects those who cannot fully protect themselves. An agreement with a person below the age of majority is void from the beginning. It cannot be enforced against the minor, and this is so even if the minor falsely claimed to be an adult. The only concession to suppliers is for necessaries suited to the minor's condition in life. A person who supplies such necessaries may recover a reasonable price from the minor's property, but the minor is not personally liable.

Q1. At the request of the village panchayat, A builds a bus shelter outside B's shop. B's business improves, and B promises to pay A ₹10,000. B does not pay.

(a) A can recover, because B benefited from the shelter.
(b) A cannot recover, because the promise was not in writing.
(c) A can recover, because past consideration is valid.
(d) A cannot recover, because the shelter was not built at B's desire.

Answer: (d).

  • (a) Wrong. Benefit to the promisor is not the test; desire is.
  • (b) Wrong. Writing is not required for ordinary consideration.
  • (c) Wrong. Past consideration counts only if done at the promisor's desire.
  • (d) Right. The act was done at the panchayat's desire.

Q2. A parent transfers a flat to their child. The same day the child signs a promise to the parent's sibling to pay them ₹5,000 a month. The child stops paying, and the sibling sues.

(a) The sibling can sue, because consideration moved from the parent and they are the promisee.
(b) The sibling cannot sue, because they gave no consideration.
(c) Only the parent can sue.
(d) The promise is void for want of registration.

Answer: (a).

  • (a) Right. The transfer of the flat is the consideration, and it came from "any other person".
  • (b) Wrong. The passage says a promisee who gave nothing may enforce the promise if someone else provided consideration.
  • (c) Wrong. The promise was made to the sibling.
  • (d) Wrong. Registration matters only in the love-and-affection exception, which does not arise here.

Q3. A promises in a signed letter to give their sibling ₹1 lakh "out of love". The letter is not registered. A changes their mind.

(a) The sibling can recover, because they are near relatives.
(b) The sibling can recover, because the promise is in writing.
(c) The promise is void, because the exception requires registration.
(d) The promise is valid as compensation for past service.

Answer: (c).

  • (a) and (b) Wrong. Each meets some conditions but not all.
  • (c) Right. All conditions of the exception must be met.
  • (d) Wrong. No past service is mentioned.

Q4. A, aged 17, tells a lender they are 19 and borrows ₹50,000. The lender sues A for repayment.

(a) A must repay, because A lied about their age.
(b) A is not bound, because the agreement is void even though A misstated their age.
(c) A must repay half.
(d) A is bound once A turns 18.

Answer: (b).

  • (a) Wrong. The passage says the lie does not change the result.
  • (b) Right.
  • (c) Wrong. The passage provides no partial liability.
  • (d) Wrong. A void agreement does not revive at majority.

Q5. A, aged 16, buys school textbooks and a winter coat on credit. A owns shares inherited from a grandparent. The seller sues for the price.

(a) The seller can recover a reasonable price from A's property, but A is not personally liable.
(b) The seller gets nothing, because agreements with minors are void.
(c) A is personally liable for the full price.
(d) The seller can recover only if A agrees after turning 18.

Answer: (a).

  • (a) Right. Textbooks and a coat are suited to a student's condition in life.
  • (b) Wrong. It ignores the necessaries concession.
  • (c) Wrong. The passage says the minor is not personally liable.
  • (d) Wrong. Later agreement is irrelevant.

Revise this

  • I can break Section 2(d) into four elements.
  • I can explain Durga Prasad and Chinnaya in one line each.
  • I can list every condition of each Section 25 exception.
  • I can state five consequences of a minor's agreement being void.
  • I know the Section 12 test of sound mind.

A note on dates and numbers. Exam patterns, vacancies and schedules change from year to year. Always confirm the current details in the latest notification on the Consortium of National Law Universities website .

Get the next CLAT guide by email

New guides every week. No spam, unsubscribe any time.