In this guide
Offer and acceptance is where most CLAT contract passages begin, and it is the area where everyday intuition misleads most. You think a price tag in a shop is an offer. You think a reply saying "yes, but…" is a yes. You think a letter of revocation cancels an offer when it is sent. Under the Indian Contract Act, 1872, none of these is right.
Here are the rules in the order passages test them, then a practice set.
The basic definitions
The Act builds a contract in steps, in Section 2:
- Proposal (offer), Section 2(a): when one person signifies to another their willingness to do or abstain from doing anything, with a view to obtaining the other's assent.
- Acceptance, Section 2(b): when the person to whom the proposal is made signifies their assent. A proposal, when accepted, becomes a promise.
- Agreement, Section 2(e): every promise and every set of promises forming the consideration for each other.
- Contract, Section 2(h): an agreement enforceable by law.
Whether an agreement becomes a contract depends on the further conditions in Section 10, covered in consideration and capacity and void agreements.
Offer or invitation to offer?
An invitation to offer asks others to make offers, and its maker stays free to accept or refuse.
| Usually an invitation to offer | Why |
|---|---|
| Goods displayed in a shop with price tags | The customer offers to buy at the till; the shop accepts or refuses |
| Advertisements, catalogues, price lists, menus | The seller cannot be bound to supply everyone who responds |
| Auctions | Each bid is an offer; the fall of the hammer is acceptance |
| Calls for tenders | Each tender is an offer |
| A reply stating the lowest acceptable price | Giving information is not agreeing to sell (Harvey v Facey, 1893) |
The exception is an advertisement that makes a clear promise to anyone who performs a condition. That is a general offer.
General offers and the need for knowledge
In Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co. (1893), the company advertised that it would pay £100 to anyone who used its smoke ball as directed and still caught influenza. A user who caught influenza sued and won. The advertisement was an offer to the world, accepted by anyone who performed the conditions. No separate notice of acceptance was needed.
Section 8 of the Act says the same: performing the conditions of a proposal is an acceptance of it.
But you cannot accept an offer you do not know about. In Lalman Shukla v Gauri Dutt (1913), an employee was sent to search for a missing boy. The employer later announced a reward for finding him. The employee found the boy without knowing of the reward, and the claim failed. There was no acceptance, because the employee did not act in response to the offer.
Acceptance must be absolute
Section 7 requires acceptance to be absolute and unqualified, and expressed in some usual and reasonable manner unless the proposal prescribes a manner.
- A conditional acceptance is a counter-offer. It rejects the original offer and makes a new one. Once rejected, the original offer cannot be revived by accepting it later (Hyde v Wrench, 1840).
- A request for information is not a counter-offer. "Would you accept payment in two instalments?" leaves the original offer open.
- Silence is not acceptance. An offeror cannot say "if I hear nothing, I will take it you agree" and bind the other side (Felthouse v Bindley, 1862).
Communication and revocation: the timing rules
Section 4 fixes the moment each communication is complete.
| Communication | Complete as against the sender | Complete as against the receiver |
|---|---|---|
| Proposal | Not relevant | When it comes to the receiver's knowledge |
| Acceptance | When put in the course of transmission, out of the acceptor's power | When it comes to the proposer's knowledge |
| Revocation | When put in the course of transmission | When it comes to the receiver's knowledge |
Section 5 then says:
- A proposal may be revoked at any time before the communication of acceptance is complete as against the proposer, but not afterwards.
- An acceptance may be revoked at any time before the communication of acceptance is complete as against the acceptor, but not afterwards.
Worked timeline
A posts an offer to B on 1 June; it reaches B on 3 June. B posts an acceptance on 4 June; it reaches A on 6 June.
- The contract binds A from 4 June, when B posts the acceptance.
- A can revoke the offer only if the revocation reaches B before B posts the acceptance on 4 June.
- B can revoke the acceptance until 6 June, for example by a phone call on 5 June that reaches A before the letter.
For instant communication such as the telephone, the Supreme Court held in Bhagwandas Goverdhandas Kedia v Girdharilal Parshottamdas (1966) that the contract is made where the acceptance is heard by the proposer.
How an offer lapses: Section 6
An offer is revoked by notice from the proposer, by the lapse of any time fixed (or a reasonable time if none is fixed), by the acceptor's failure to meet a condition precedent, or by the proposer's death or insanity if the acceptor learns of it before accepting.
Practice passage
Passage
A contract begins when one person makes a proposal and another accepts it. Not every statement about a sale is a proposal. When a seller displays goods, publishes a price list or advertises a product, the seller ordinarily invites others to make proposals. The customer who comes forward makes the proposal, and the seller is free to accept or decline it.
Some announcements, however, are proposals made to the public at large, such as a promise of a reward to anyone who finds a lost article. Such a proposal is accepted by performing its conditions. But acceptance is a response to a proposal, so a person who performs the conditions without knowing of the proposal has not accepted it.
An acceptance must be absolute and unqualified. A reply that changes the terms is not an acceptance but a fresh proposal, and it puts an end to the original proposal.
Where parties communicate by post, the communication of an acceptance is complete as against the proposer when the letter is posted, and as against the acceptor when it reaches the proposer. A proposal may be revoked only before the acceptance is complete as against the proposer. A revocation takes effect against the person to whom it is made only when it reaches them.
Q1. An online store lists a phone at ₹1,999 instead of ₹19,999 by mistake. A buyer places an order at ₹1,999. Before sending any acceptance, the store cancels the order.
(a) There is a contract, because the store displayed the price.
(b) There is no contract, because the price was a mistake.
(c) There is a contract, because the buyer paid online.
(d) There is no contract, because the listing was an invitation, the order was the proposal, and the store never accepted it.
Answer: (d).
- (a) Wrong. A display is an invitation, not a proposal.
- (b) Wrong. Right result, wrong reason: the passage says nothing about mistakes in price.
- (c) Wrong. The facts do not say payment was taken, and payment is not acceptance by the store.
- (d) Right. The proposal came from the buyer and was declined before acceptance.
Q2. A notice at a railway station promises ₹5,000 to anyone who returns a lost dog. A person finds the dog wandering and returns it the same evening, then sees the notice and claims the reward.
(a) Entitled, because the conditions were performed.
(b) Not entitled, because the conditions were performed without knowledge of the proposal.
(c) Entitled, because the notice was a proposal to the public.
(d) Not entitled, because a reward notice is only an invitation.
Answer: (b).
- (a) and (c) Wrong. Both ignore the knowledge requirement.
- (b) Right. This is the rule from Lalman Shukla, stated in the passage.
- (d) Wrong. The passage treats a reward promise as a proposal to the public.
Q3. A offers to sell a car to B for ₹5 lakh. B replies, "I will pay ₹4.5 lakh." A refuses. B then writes, "All right, I accept ₹5 lakh." A has since found another buyer.
(a) No contract. B's reply was a fresh proposal that ended A's original proposal, so there was nothing left to accept.
(b) A contract at ₹5 lakh was formed by B's second letter.
(c) A contract at ₹4.5 lakh was formed.
(d) No contract, because the price was not agreed in writing.
Answer: (a).
- (a) Right. The counter-proposal ended it, and B's second letter is only a new proposal.
- (b) Wrong. The original proposal no longer existed.
- (c) Wrong. A refused that proposal.
- (d) Wrong. Writing is not a requirement in the passage.
Q4. A posts a proposal to B on 1 June. On 2 June, A posts a revocation. B posts an acceptance on 3 June. The revocation reaches B on 4 June.
(a) No contract, because A revoked first.
(b) No contract, because the acceptance had not reached A.
(c) A contract, because the acceptance was complete against A on 3 June, before the revocation reached B.
(d) A contract only if B's letter reaches A.
Answer: (c).
- (a) Wrong. A revocation takes effect against B only when it reaches B, which was 4 June.
- (b) and (d) Wrong. Arrival matters only for the acceptor's own revocation.
- (c) Right. Posting on 3 June completed the acceptance against A, and after that A could not revoke.
Common mistakes
- Calling a shop display, catalogue or menu an offer.
- Forgetting that a counter-offer kills the original offer.
- Treating a revocation as effective against the other party when it is posted.
- Assuming a reward can be claimed by anyone who performed the act, known or not.
Revise this
- I can define proposal, acceptance, promise, agreement and contract.
- I can list four common invitations to offer.
- I can explain Carlill and Lalman Shukla in one line each.
- I can draw a postal timeline and mark when each party is bound.
- I know the four ways an offer lapses under Section 6.
A note on dates and numbers. Exam patterns, vacancies and schedules change from year to year. Always confirm the current details in the latest notification on the Consortium of National Law Universities website .
Get the next CLAT guide by email
New guides every week. No spam, unsubscribe any time.